Synology NAS DS423
Synology NAS DS423
The Synology NAS was my first real entry point into Homelabbing and really opened my eyes into the true difference between $20/m for 2TB cloud storage vs 16TB Local Storage on a low power device - for the longest time my homelab was dominated by this box as a Storage Node
If So Great, then Why Leave?
As this was my first real home labbing project, my services and needs beyond a very basic Plex Server running media started growing faster than the performance of the Synology box could really keep up with despite:
Realtek RTD1619B, quad-core 1.7 GHz
2 GB DDR4 RAM (soldered)
4 Hot Swappable Disk Bays
2 x 1GbE RJ-45 LAN ports
2 x USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports
Power Consumption: Approximately 32.41 W during active access and 4.97 W during HDD hibernation.
...that last point was a real sticking point for me - and if you're a novice to homelabbing, or don't have technical knowledge yet, the synology web UI is familiar and helpful to navigate and learn on - however, as I began to experiment with docker containers on other machines, Container Manager, once seeming so helpful and intuitive began to feel like constraints.
Over time, this setup became limiting, i didn't just want storage that worked, i wanted to understand how it worked. I wanted to design my own RAID layouts, control how disks were grouped, debug issues at the system level and build storage as part of a larger system, not a standalone appliance, i have too many computers already and wanted to shrink it down as much as possible. That's when i knew it was time to move on to Syrup Mark 2
Synology makes great products - so great that despite a growing itch for greater storage node resources, one of the main sticking points was the fact it sips on power at idle, the OS is very beginner friendly (very appreciated at this point) - add on top the fact that:
TrueNAS - Rigid ZFS constraints, at this point in time i have been spoiled by Synology's SHR RAID set up and was now willing to make the concessions ZFS demands
Unraid - booting from a USB is not something i'm comfortable with on a machine which needs as much uptime as possible